Simulations & Analysis

Experiment with Different Design Solutions & Costs Before you Build

Summary Sheet: Run Comparison

 

Detail Sheet for a Specific Run



Utility Comparison - original house on Westside and the PDR remodeled house  

For our house remodel we really wanted to have  a better idea of the  results or impacts of our energy efficient improvements. We needed a tool that could (a) help us learn by trial and error; and (b) give us data-based feedback on specific design improvements. This is why we developed our own thermal simulations - which provide both of these capabilities.

A  House  "System"

There are  a number of parameters or variables that can be investigated to simulate how a house will perform thermally:

  • Window R-values and SHGC
  • Insulation R-values, Infiltration, Air Changes/Hour (ACPH)
  • Site Orientation, Number of Degree Days
  • Amount and Location of Glazing
  • Thermal Mass - Type and Amount inside House

Since we were remodeling we had certain constraints on our design. For example, our North wall was going to stay 2X4 framing while the rest of the house would be 2X6 framing.  We opted for the larger framing so we could obtain a higher R-value in the walls.  We did have great southern exposure and wanted to maximize that by capturing and holding the incoming energy of the Sun.  How would we do that with a raised foundation (no cement slab to act as a thermal mass)?  Well, we intended to use a new kind of wallboard - phase change wallboard - that is able to hold and release energy over the course of a day.  We'll come back to that issue .

In the end, our Thermal Simulations demonstrated that for our location, climate and site orientation the windows and insulation would be critical in providing an efficient building envelope. In fact, a well insulated building with high performance windows was our minimum design criteria. Our analysis accounted for the size, location, R-values, SHGC  of all the windows; the types of insulation used in the walls, floors and ceilings; solar insolation at the site; air changes / hour as well as the different types of thermal mass in the house.  Our craftsman style house had a lot of wood in the design including the very desnse Acacia wood in addition to the normal furniture, cabinets, tables, granite, tile, etc.  Our simulations showed us that this incident themal mass would indeed help to moderate temperature swings in the house.

Design Analysis 

We can look at a few of our simulations for PDR, called "runs" to help demonstrate things.  Take a look at the  (1) Run Comparison and (2) Detail Sheet  below.  It is probalby easier to talk about these or answer you specific questions - send an email with your questions.

 

A summary sheet or "Run Comparison" is prepared that graphically represents the relative change in performance of the differnt design decisions. A number of performance metrics are used.

A "Detail Sheet" with all the specific run data is created for each design. The Details Sheet records all the relevant design decisions; graphs the 24-hour termperature and heat flow (Q) data, and tracks the changes in a critical set of  metrics.

Next: Energy Efficiency